Donald Trump’s “Civil war” social media repost has some commentators asking whether it could be evidence to disqualify him for running for office again.
The former president received widespread condemnation for sharing the post—written by another user—on Truth Social, the platform Trump set up after he was banned from Twitter in the wake of January 6 over fears he would incite further violence.
Author, journalist and attorney Seth Abramson was one of those who suggested that Trump resharing the post bolsters an “already-strong case” that Trump should be disqualified for running for president in 2024 under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment
It states that those who “engaged in insurrection or rebellion” after taking a congressional oath should be prevented from running for office.
For more than 150 years, it was little thought of. Today, however, it is often cited by those calling for the removal of politicians linked to events at the U.S. Capitol on January 6.
Eric J. Segall, professor of law at Georgia State University College of Law, suggested that there are still too many unanswered questions about the clause before it might be used, including if constitutional oaths follow presidents after they leave the White House.
Segall told Newsweek however, that such questions are immaterial because there is no indication that Congress would initiate proceedings over the post.
“If that was going to be done, it would have been done before because he was in office on January 6,” Segall said. “He engaged in actual insurrection on that day, and the months before that.
“Those acts do disqualify him. But what he does after January 20, 2020, I’m not sure.”
Reposting a comment on social media is unlikely to be enough, Segall added.
“If it says we should go to civil war then we could talk, but even then he’s not in office right now.”
Laurence Tribe, professor of Constitutional Law Emeritus at Harvard University, also suggested that there is no need to discuss whether the “civil war” post should disqualify Trump from office as he already should be due to his actions in and around January 6.
“Those who’re saying this amounts to ‘insurrection’ disqualifying Trump from running for office under Sec 3 of 14th Am are undermining the REAL basis for deeming Trump an insurrectionist: Jan 6 & related ACTS, not 1st A protected SPEECH,” Tribe tweeted.
Republican leader Trump is widely expected to run for president in 2024, although he has not confirmed a bid. His representatives have been contacted for comment.
The 14th Amendment has previously been cited in legal challengers from groups hoping to disbar people from office over the January 6 attack. That includes Georgia congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene and North Carolina Rep. Madison Cawthorn.
However, a Georgia judge rejected an effort to disqualify Green for running for office again, ruling there was “insufficient” evidence to suggest she supported an insurrection.
Attempts to bar Cawthorn from running again ultimately proved fruitless as he lost his GOP primary to State Senator Chuck Edwards.
Trump became the first president in history to be impeached twice over accusations he incited his supporters to storm the Capitol on January 6 in order to stop the certification of the electoral votes in favor of Joe Biden .
The Senate later acquitted Trump of inciting the riot, paving the way for him to be allowed to run for the presidency again in 2024.
- To many Vietnamese, US still a top overseas study destination in spite of Donald Trump
- Donald Trump is 'totally nuts,' says Robert de Niro
- Donald Trump lashes out at 'crooked media'
- Boycotts and nuclearisation: Canada defiant of Trump
- Trump in Paris slams Macron's 'insulting' EU army proposals
- World can 'sleep well' after North Korea summit, Trump says
- Macron and Trump: "Frenemies" in open disagreement
- Trump to honour Macron, his unlikely French friend
- Trump set to announce Iran sanctions move that may kill nuclear deal
- China US agree to abandon trade war: China's vice premier
- Germany asks Trump envoy to clarify 'empowering' right call
- Trump Is Winning His Trade War With China. Here's Why That Might Not Last
- Trump announces US withdrawal from 'defective' Iran deal
- White House bars CNN reporter after verbal duel with Trump
- Trump backs potential new auto import tariffs
- Vietnam "willing" to host Trump Kim summit: Report
- Asian traders cautious after G7 debacle, eyes on Trump Kim summit
- Trump threatened to send 25 million Mexicans to Japan: Report
- Trump deepens G7 divide with call to readmit Russia
- European markets run out of steam on caution over North Korea summit
Could Donald Trump's civil war post disqualify him from running in 2024? have 733 words, post on www.newsweek.com at May 24, 2022. This is cached page on Europe Breaking News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.