As recommendations go, it was lukewarm, to say the least.
On Monday, Prof Chris Whitty, the Chief Medical Officer for England, told the nation that "on balance" children aged 12 to 15 should be vaccinated, before providing only vague reasons to back up the decision.
The Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI) has already ruled that the benefits are so marginal for schoolchildren that the jabs were not worth the risk .
However, after 10 days of mulling over the wider advantages to education and mental health, the chief medical officers of the four nations decided to approve a rollout .
"What we're not trying to do is say to children 'You must, must, must, must, must'," said Prof Whitty.
"What we're saying is we think, on balance, the benefits both at an individual level, and in terms of wider indirect benefits to education and through that to public health, are in favour."
Prof Whitty insisted that it would not be a "silver bullet", but said it was a "potentially useful tool" to help reduce the health impacts that come through educational disruption.
"The disruption in education that has happened in the last period since March 2020 has been extraordinarily difficult for children and has a big impact on health, mental health and long-term public health," he added.
Undoubtedly, children have been disproportionately impacted by the pandemic for their level of risk , which is very, very small.
A study by University College London (UCL) published in July found that just 25 under-18s died in the first 12 months of the pandemic, yet their worlds have been turned upside down by lockdowns, school closures and the bubble system which saw hundreds of thousands of children forced to isolate at home.
At the end of July, a study by the University of Oxford found that 98.4 per cent of children who were sent home for 10 days under the bubble system never went on to develop Covid.
On a longer-term level, studies have shown that education is one of the strongest determinants of health and longevity and there is strong evidence that school closures increase isolation , reduce physical activity, and cut off children from peers and social support.
A study by UCL of 20 countries which had experienced school closures found that between 18 and 60 per cent of youngsters scored above risk thresholds for distress, particularly anxiety and depressive symptoms.
However, the problem with Monday's advice is that it comes after the Government already has made a commitment to get rid of bubbles and national lockdowns , and keep children in school as much as possible, hugely cutting down on disruption to education.
There also appears to be little science backing up claims that the vaccinations will limit spread in schools.
Prof Whitty said he was "expecting" the vaccination programme to reduce the number of outbreaks in schools and added that it would be "
The chief medical officers of the UK are estimating that one jab will reduce the chance of a child catching coronavirus by 50 to 55 per cent. But that is based on data in adults, so it is unknown if it will translate to youngsters. And given that children are largely asymptomatic, how much that will impact transmission in classrooms is unknown.
There is compelling evidence that outbreaks in schools are largely driven by teachers, not pupils. The University of Warwick has repeatedly found evidence that schools are not responsible for spreading Covid, with schools lagging cases in the community, suggesting infections are linked to growth in the wider environment.
When asked whether he would definitely recommend it, Prof Whitty said: "Our view is this is over the line, otherwise we wouldn't be making this recommendation."
However, he admitted: "The size of the effect is inevitably smaller than for people in their 40s, 50s, 60s, but children do still have problems with Covid."
Earlier in a background press briefing, a source close to the Government summed up the confusion: "We think it is highly improbable that vaccination alone will prevent disruption to education, and we think it highly improbable that vaccination will not have a positive effect in reducing the amount of disruption."
On Monday night, the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health warned that disruption in schools would not ease until mass testing was scrapped in favour of targeting children with symptoms.
"Routine testing of children without symptoms is still interrupting children and teenagers' school attendance and we do not believe this should continue," it said in a statement.
"Tackling this pandemic, which is still ongoing, does not depend on vaccinating children , who have already borne a great deal on behalf of us all."
Critics of the way that the Government has handled the announcement point out that if the JCVI did not feel it could safely recommend it, how can parents and children be expected to know what is best?
Only time will tell if the Government has done enough to reassure families .
- More than 5,000 Britons have volunteered to take part in the world's biggest trial to find a treatment for COVID-19 - and it includes the anti-malaria drug touted by Donald Trump
- In the shadow of Ebola and Covid-19, measles rips through Congo
- Coronavirus latest: Trump says US is 'terminating' ties with WHO
- Could nearly half of those with Covid-19 have no idea they are infected?
- From AIDS to Covid-19: Trump's decades of spreading dangerous misinformation about disease outbreaks
- ‘Angels without wings’ helped save a couple in their 80s from COVID-19
- How having a cold could protect you from Covid-19: Scientists uncover MORE evidence that fighting off mild respiratory bugs may make you immune to the coronavirus
- COVID-19 Is Surging. Donald Trump’s Response Is Shrinking
- Pete Evans now says he is 'pro safe vaccine' - after being blasted for claiming there's a link between jabs and behavioural changes in children
- DR MICHAEL MOSLEY'S battle plan to fight Coronavirus: Being overweight can be a killer if you catch COVID-19 and Britons have piled on the pounds in lockdown... this diet really could save your life
- [Full Speech] COVID-19 and Nigeria security issues: The way forward ― Obasanjo
- Hillary Clinton & Nanette Burstein Talk COVID-19, 2020 Vote, 2016 Ghosts And Other Tales From Hulu Docuseries ‘Hillary’
- How do we beat coronavirus? Bill Gates says start with these 4 things
- The Hill's Coronavirus Report: CDC predicts US death toll could reach 145,000 by July 11; Premier President Michael Alkire says more resiliency needed in health supply chain
- The Hill's Coronavirus Report: Cure Violence Global founder Gary Slutkin says violence and epidemics follow same patterns; Global death toll surpasses half a million
- The Hill's Coronavirus Report: BIO's Michelle McMurry-Heath says 400 projects started in 16 weeks in biotech firms to fight virus, pandemic unemployment total tops 43 million
- Hollowed Out US Public Health System Faces More Cuts Amid Virus
- Minnesota AG Keith Ellison says racism is a bigger problem than police behavior; 21 states see uptick in cases amid efforts to reopen
- How lab animals have fared in the coronavirus crisis
- The Hill's Morning Report - Presented by Facebook - Trump wants schools to reopen, challenged on 'harmless' COVID-19 remark
What does the science say about whether children should get the Covid vaccine? have 1191 words, post on www.telegraph.co.uk at September 13, 2021. This is cached page on Europe Breaking News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.