Two mystery parties try to restrict release of documents in Jeffrey Epstein civil suit
Where are they now? The biggest players in the Jeffrey Epstein case
Two mysterious parties, labeling themselves Jane Doe and John Doe, have filed separate legal briefs in an attempt to limit the public release of personal information that could connect them to an underage sex trafficking operation allegedly run by New York financier Jeffrey Epstein and his partner, Ghislaine Maxwell.
Jane Doe, represented by Kerrie Campbell, a Washington-based gender equality lawyer, appears to be a victim who wants to remain unidentified, but indicated she is amicable to the release of some information — as long as it doesn’t identify her, court documents filed this week show.
The other party, John Doe, submitted a brief in support of Maxwell, who continues to mount a last-ditch legal campaign to keep court records that allegedly contain details of their sex exploits involving young girls — and other third party people who may be involved — under seal.
It’s not clear whether the latest challenges will delay release of the documents, said Sanford Bohrer, attorney for the Miami Herald, which filed an action to unseal the files last year as part of its investigation into Epstein called “Perversion of Justice.’’
The court case currently at issue is a 2015 defamation lawsuit filed against Maxwell by Virginia Roberts Giuffre, who claims she was recruited by Maxwell at Mar-a-Lago, President Donald Trump’s resort in Palm Beach, when she was 16 years old. She says Maxwell brought her to Epstein’s mansion and she was trafficked for sex to a number of prominent and powerful men.
John Doe, in his amicus brief, claims that he was not party to the Maxwell lawsuit, and has never been publicly identified or accused by Giuffre of being a co-conspirator of Epstein or “a person with whom she had sexual relations,’’ according to the brief, filed Tuesday by lawyers Nicholas J. Lewin, Paul M. Krieger and Nicholas F. Bolz in New York.
“So if he didn’t do anything, then why doesn’t he want to be identified?’’ Bohrer said.
Virginia Roberts was working at Mar-a-Lago when she was recruited to be a masseuse to Palm Beach hedge fund manager Jeffrey Epstein. She was lured into a life of depravity and sexual abuse.
“We know that ‘John’ isn’t a victim — so his best scenario is he believes he is wrongly accused. But that’s the purpose of this process — you don’t get to seal it for that reason. We should have facts, compelling facts, that indicate a legally protectable interest that is so compelling that it justifies denying public access.’’
Maxwell’s attorneys on Tuesday filed a motion in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in New York to prevent enforcement of an earlier decision by the court to release a large portion of the files. Based on the filings, the case is believed to contain a range of evidence, including testimony from other possible underage victims who say they were trafficked.
All parties to the case, including the Herald, have agreed to redact the names of minors, Social Security numbers and other details that would identify victims.
“Large parts of that court record — not just Ms. Giuffre’s allegations — are in the public interest, especially today,’’ Bohrer told the court in his oral arguments on March 6. “Mr. Epstein — for good or bad — is a focus of some things that are really important … and we feel this is something the public really needs to know about.
“More generally, the whole point of having records open … is for the public to see how the judges are doing and how the criminal justice system works.’’
Giuffre, who settled the suit against Maxwell in 2017, also wants the files made public, arguing in a counter filing that Maxwell has failed to meet the court’s threshold of providing “compelling reasons’’ to keep the documents under seal.
“Ms. Maxwell is dodging a key point: The summary judgment findings focused on whether Ms. Maxwell was an essential co-conspirator in Epstein’s international sex trafficking organization,’’ Giuffre’s lawyers wrote. “It may be be ‘embarrassing’ for Ms. Maxwell to have the world know the scope of her involvement in trafficking underage girls internationally for sexual purposes. But her involvement in a criminal enterprise does not remotely approach any legitimate ground for sealing.’’
The three-judge appeals court ruled in the Herald’s favor on March 11. Thirty-two other media companies, including The New York Times and The Washington Post, supported the Herald’s effort.
A Miami Herald investigation into Palm Beach hedge fund manager Jeffrey Epstein’s sexual pyramid scheme targeting underage girls– and why he’s a free man today.
“Our precedent clearly establishes that ‘documents submitted to a court for its consideration in a summary judgment motion are — as a matter of law — judicial documents to which a strong presumption of access attaches, under both the common law and the First Amendment,’ ” the judges wrote, citing case law.
But the panel nevertheless gave the parties until March 19 to establish good cause as to why documents in the civil suit should remain sealed. In the wake of recently filed briefs, the deadline had been delayed.
The Herald’s lawyer has outlined a process for the release of the documents whereby representatives for all the parties will participate in a document-by-document review to determine what should remain redacted or sealed. The court appeared to be agreeable to that procedure.
Giuffre, who now lives in Australia, asserted that she was directed to have sex with public figures — including Prince Andrew and lawyer Alan Dershowitz, both of whom have denied her allegations and alleged that because she has made them only in court documents, which protect her from being sued, she is using that privilege to make false claims. Giuffre, in an interview last year, told the Herald that Epstein had cameras around many of his properties and homes and may have used her to have leverage over influential people.
Dershowitz filed his own appeal to unseal documents in the Maxwell case. He believes the case history contains documents that will exonerate him. Also party to the appeal is social media blogger Michael Cernovich.
Ultimately, Maxwell settled the case in 2017 before trial. Maxwell, the daughter of the late publishing tycoon Robert Maxwell, has denied all allegations against her, claiming that the lawsuit was filed to gain publicity and notoriety and to profit from the allegations.
Jeffrey Epstein, a multimillionaire who molested dozens of underage girls, and is suspected of trafficking countless other girls around the world, issued a public apology Tuesday. It was not to the victims of his abuse, but to one of their lawyers.
Epstein, who was not party to the lawsuit, has denied he ever ran a sex trafficking operation. In 2005, he came under investigation by Palm Beach police, accused of molesting three dozen underage girls by luring them to his mansion under the guise of paying them for massages.
Eventually, under a secret plea deal negotiated by then-Miami U.S. Attorney Alexander Acosta, Epstein pleaded guilty to two prostitution charges in state court and served 13 months in the county jail, where he enjoyed liberal work release privileges despite that being prohibited for sex offenders.
In November, the Miami Herald published a series of articles that deconstructed how Epstein and his lawyers manipulated the criminal justice system, working secretly with federal prosecutors to conceal and minimize his crimes. The handling of the case is now under investigation by the Department of Justice.
On March 4, some of Epstein’s lawyers wrote an op-ed letter to The New York Times denying that Epstein ran a sex trafficking ring and contending that the number of women involved in his criminal case was “vastly exaggerated.’’
Acosta, who is now President Trump’s secretary of labor, has come under pressure by some in Congress to resign his post, but the president on Tuesday expressed his support.
Related stories from Miami Herald
November 26, 2018 06:13 PM
November 26, 2018 06:13 PM
March 19, 2019 08:37 PM
March 20, 2019 06:27 PM
March 20, 2019 10:46 AM
March 19, 2019 06:03 AM
March 19, 2019 07:17 PM
Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has intensified a push for U.S. recognition of Israeli control over Golan Heights, disputed territory with Syria, hoping that President Donald Trump will deliver a diplomatic victory during his visit to Washington.
- Where is Jean Luc Brunel, the mysterious French modeling agent linked to Jeffrey Epstein’s alleged sex trafficking ring?
- Remembering the Time Jeffrey Epstein Rode on Donald Trump’s Plane
- Jeffrey Epstein 'forced underage girls to have sex with Prince Andrew so that he could get incriminating information to use as potential blackmail'
- Royal insider says claims Prince Andrew 'put pressure on the US government to give Jeffrey Epstein a plea deal' when he was jailed for 18 months in 2008 is a 'straight forward untruth'
- Virginia Roberts tells how she performed a sex act on Ghislaine Maxwell in front of Jeffrey Epstein by the pool on his private island and pedophile's 'madam' had 'continuous' orgies with young girls, unsealed court documents claim
- How Jeffrey Epstein abused underage girls for years 'with the help of Ghislaine Maxwell' as the 'power couple' lived a lavish lifestyle flying to his mansions around the world on the Lolita Express before his arrest and suicide
- Former Victoria's Secret CEO agreed to written deposition in Epstein accuser suit
- Ghislaine Maxwell latest news: Prince Andrew ‘used Spitting Image puppet to grope women at Jeffrey Epstein’s mansion’
- Woman claims she was raped by Jeffrey Epstein at his New York mansion at 17 while Prince Andrew was in another room and the billionaire pedophile said: 'I know you love it'
- EXCLUSIVE: Jeffrey Epstein victim who says he and Ghislaine Maxwell recruited her at age 13 from summer camp in Michigan and performed 'malicious acts of sexual abuse' over five years is suing the pedophile's estate for more than $25million
- How We Got the Scoop on Jeffrey Epstein’s Arrest
- Jeffrey Epstein pleasured himself while Ghislaine Maxwell sexually abused 15-year-old Virginia Roberts, docs claim
- Ghislaine Maxwell - Jeffrey Epstein's 'madam' and friend of Prince Andrew - is held in custody to be transferred from New Hampshire to New York to face child sex trafficking charges as prosecutors ask judge to deny bail and say she is a flight risk
- Prince Andrew 'used Spitting Image puppet of himself to grope Virginia Roberts and another woman in Jeffrey Epstein's New York House of Horrors', bombshell new court documents claim
- Friend of Ghislaine Maxwell claims she asked him to wear Jeffrey Epstein's karate suit to perform a 'creepy' song at the paedophile's 40th birthday party - and was desperate for approval because of her 'monster' father
- 'He got off on my terror' Jeffrey Epstein victim recalls being abused as a 19-year-old virgin and says friends like Prince Andrew must give evidence to the FBI
- Prince Andrew’s ‘foot-licking fetish’ made Jeffrey Epstein burst into laughter, sex slave claims in court docs
- Sex slave who worked on Jeffrey Epstein's 'Lolita Express' private jet claims a 'massage guru' introduced her to Ghislaine Maxwell after she was approached at a Hollywood party
- Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein ‘seemed sexually aroused by Virginia Roberts’ stories of being abused by paedos’
- Ghislaine Maxwell is seen cavorting with fugitive rape suspect Jean-Luc Brunel - who 'gave Jeffrey Epstein three 12-year-old sisters to abuse as a birthday present' - in newly uncovered photos taken on 'paedophile island'
Two mystery parties try to restrict release of documents in Jeffrey Epstein civil suit have 2672 words, post on www.miamiherald.com at November 26, 2018. This is cached page on Europe Breaking News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.